Testing a Multilevel Oscillatory Hierarchy: A Finite-Work Toy Model, Negative Results, and Open Physical Bridges
A controlled attempt to turn the residue/higher-order renewal architecture into a minimum finite-work toy model, preserving consistency checks, failed gates, and unresolved physical interfaces.
Abstract
Earlier work introduced a multilevel oscillatory hierarchy (MOH) as a conceptual architecture in which a lower cosmological order may collapse and renew from a history-bearing residue while a higher-order sector continues along its own trajectory. Here we test that architecture with a staged finite-work toy model. The construction does not yield a physically closed or predictive cosmological renewal model. The R channel carries the working concept of inherited sensitivity: prior history can change the later realized response of an otherwise comparable residue. In the tested model, history-correlated residue changes first-passage accessibility relative to matched shuffle controls. Within an expanded-state description, however, the implemented inherited sensitivity is representable as history-dependent hidden-state dynamics; the present test therefore does not establish independent physical content or predictive superiority for the R/H decomposition, and its physical carrier and readout law remain open. Within the chosen reciprocal-energy/positive-mobility model class, a reciprocal higher-order/formation functional generates formation work dynamically and satisfies an exact work identity. A scale-free relational map from premetric proto-organization to a traceless homogeneous shape variable provides a conditional candidate for newborn intrinsic geometry, with dimensionality and coframe promotion kept explicit as assumptions. When a positive homogeneous geometry burden is inserted into the same common work account, the predeclared strict no-retuning gate fails at every tested positive load at the frozen formation thresholds. This rejects the tested friction-like homogeneous-geometry bridge, not geometry emergence in general. No mechanism is obtained that generically produces a low-Weyl cosmological initial state: the homogeneous construction remains conditional and the inhomogeneous low-Weyl extension remains blocked. Subsequent normalization and stress-closure audits show that direct canonical continuation of the higher-order coordinate into the newborn scale factor fails, already-accounted higher-order work cannot be spent again, and the post-emergent mean stress required for accelerated expansion remains undetermined. The paper therefore reports a controlled model-development attempt, preserving both consistency checks and negative results, and identifies the independent physical bridges that would be required before stronger cosmological claims are justified.
Results at a glance
- PASS — Reciprocal finite-work formation: the exact work identity closes within the chosen reciprocal-energy/positive-mobility model class, with explicit backreaction. No cosmological carrier is established.
- CONDITIONAL — History-sensitive readout and homogeneous shape: history-correlated residue changes accessibility relative to matched controls, but is representable as hidden-state dynamics. The intrinsic-shape map still assumes dimensionality, coframe promotion, and physical normalization.
- FAIL — Tested positive geometry-load bridge: every predeclared positive friction-like load fails the frozen formation gate. This result applies to that proxy bridge; it does not rule out geometry emergence in general.
- FAIL — Direct higher-order coordinate to scale-factor continuation: the naive canonical identification encounters the wrong kinetic sign. Work already accounted for cannot be spent again.
- OPEN — Physical interfaces: trace normalization, the post-emergent constitutive stress-energy relation, the physical carrier of inherited sensitivity, and the origin of higher orders remain unresolved.
- BLOCKED — W3 and acceleration prediction: the inhomogeneous low-Weyl extension awaits independently justified homogeneous coupling and normalization; numerical acceleration prediction awaits post-emergent constitutive stress-energy.
Data and code
The companion reproducibility package v1.1, dated 2 October 2026, contains retained source records and executable scripts, frozen protocols, archived and recomputed machine-readable outputs, a claim manifest, a provenance/status ledger, and SHA-256 checksums.
The archive distinguishes exact executable reruns, source-data audits, and analytic audits. Some historical simulators are not available as complete executable code; the README and verification report identify those limits. The package supports the retained claims and frozen negative results rather than the entire exploratory development history.
Data and code archive DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.23110906.
Suggested citation
Preprint:
Kafara, M. (2026). Testing a Multilevel Oscillatory Hierarchy: A Finite-Work Toy Model, Negative Results, and Open Physical Bridges (v0.20-final) [Preprint]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23110649
Data and code:
Kafara, M. (2026). MOH reproducibility package: Testing a multilevel oscillatory hierarchy — finite-work toy model, negative results, and open physical bridges (v1.1). Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23110906
Keywords
multilevel oscillatory hierarchy; cosmological renewal; inherited sensitivity; nonequilibrium self-organization; emergent geometry; Weyl curvature; backreaction; dynamical accessibility; stress-energy closure